Twilight by Stephenie Meyer [YA Fiction]
by a 10th grader
I’m in the minority, unfortunately. I’m a teenage girl that dislikes Twilight. I get that it’s a book that exists purely as wish fulfillment, which isn’t a bad thing- but it doesn’t deserve all the praise it gets. The writing is mediocre at best. We get it. Edward’s gorgeous, Adonis-like, he looks like a model, and he’s amazing. We get that Bella’s clumsy… we get it!! Stephenie Meyer, you have some fixation with adverbs and obscure vocabulary words you probably pulled from a thesaurus to make yourself sound smart.
The characters, namely our protagonists, are flat at best. Bella is plain, average, and clumsy, and yet all the Forks boys want to date her, and everyone wants to be her friend. Edward is broody and beautiful, and that’s about it. Their chemistry is even flatter. They have all of two conversations before they’re in “one true love”. No actual conversations, no joking, or even becoming legitimate FRIENDS- just the two of them looking at each other and swooning about how beautiful they are.
Also… sparkling? REALLY??
by Jill, 6th grader
I know everyone loved Twilight, but I didn’t like it. It’s just another Cinderella story without the glass slipper. Bella falls head over heels in love with Edward, but the twist is that Edward is a vampire. There are events along the way, but in the end it’s happy ever after. Twilight was hands down the worst book I have ever read. I recommend that you NEVER read Twilight unless you think Edward is cute- which he isn’t!!